Lee Romero

On Content, Collaboration and Findability

Archive for January 18th, 2021

Evaluating enterprise search – standards?

Monday, January 18th, 2021

Over the past several years of working very closely with the enterprise search solution at Deloitte, I have tried to look “outside” as best as I can in order to understand what others in the industry are doing to evaluate their solutions in order to understand where ours ‘fits’.

I’ve attended a number of conferences and webcasts and read papers (many, I’ll admit, that are highlighted by Martin White on Twitter. I can’t recommend a follow of Martin enough!)

One thing I have never found is any common way to evaluate or talk about enterprise search solutions. I have seen several people (including Martin) comment on the relatively little research on enterprise search (as opposed to internet search, which has a lot of research behind it), and I am sure a significant reason for that is that there is no common way to evaluate the solutions.

If we could compare in a systematic way, we could start to understand how to do things like:

  • Identify common use cases that are visible in user behavior (via metrics)
  • Compare how ‘good’ different solutions are at meeting the core need (an employee needs to access some resource to do their job)
  • Compare different industries approaches to information seeking (again, as identified by user behavior via metrics) – for example, do users search differently in industrial companies vs. professional services companies vs. research companies?

Why do we not have a common set of definitions?

One possibility is certainly that I have still not read up enough on the topic – perhaps there is a common set of definitions – if so, feel free to share.

Another possibility is that this is a result of dependency on the metrics that are implemented within the search solutions enterprises are using. I have found that these are useful but they don’t come with a lot of detail or clarity of definition. And, more specifically, they don’t seem common across products. That said, I have relatively limited exposure to multiple search solutions – Again, I would be interested in insights from those who have (perhaps any consultants working in this space?)

And, one more possible driver behind a lack of commonality is the proprietary nature of most implementations. I try to speak externally as frequently as I can, but I am always hesitant (and have been coached) to not be too detailed on the implementation.

I do plan to put up a small series here, though, with some of the more elemental components of our metrics implementation for comparison with anyone who cares to share.

More soon!